"One Life to Live" Ignites New Rape Controversy

One Life to Live, Trevor St. John, Todd Manning
Trevor St. John as rapist Todd Manning on ABC's "One Life to Live."

Published: November 13, 2008 at 01:52 AM GMT
Last Updated: November 13, 2008 at 01:52 AM GMT

By Ed Martin

The most riveting and engrossing drama on broadcast television during the November 2008 sweeps period to date isn’t happening on CBSCSI, ABC’s Grey’s Anatomy, FoxHouse or NBC’s Heroes – or anywhere in primetime, for that matter. It is playing out on ABC Daytime’s One Life to Live. This show is sizzling right now, with multiple storylines concluding, colliding and cascading off in wild new directions that will play out for months or years to come. The past, present and future of the show are all in skillful play. From a structural perspective – a critical element of superior serialized drama – this is some of the best soap opera storytelling I have seen in years. It is simply extraordinary in its simultaneous clarity and complexity. (Maybe the writing team on NBC’s increasingly disappointing Heroes should sit down with the gang at OLTL and ask them how it’s done.)
Unfortunately, there has been much unpleasantness at the center of it all, and no joy whatsoever, except for the births of a few puppies. As skilled as they are at story structure and characterization, I sometimes wonder if the writers, producers and network executives who are in charge of this show realize that if OLTL is to endure it must appeal to (rather than repel) women. For example, there have been entirely too many close-ups in recent days of a stillborn baby delivered last week by one of the main characters. I can deal with this tragic story development, because the child is at the center of so much drama involving so many characters, and the story has been extremely well played by the many actors involved. (They’re an amazing group.) But I don’t believe women want to see dead babies in their entertainment. Not ever.
As disturbing and upsetting as the story of Jessica’s baby has been, though, it has often been quite moving -- and it has never been offensive. That distinction goes to the other big OLTL drama of the month – the show’s veteran psychopath Todd Manning having sex with Marty Saybrook, the young woman he savagely attacked 15 years ago in what remains one of the most powerful stories in the history of daytime drama. Todd and two other young men in 1993 executed the brutal gang rape of Marty, then a disturbed young woman. (Todd was, in fact, the ringleader.) Those scenes were more intense than just about anything that had ever been shown on daytime television. The stunning story earned an armload of Emmy Awards, including honors for Susan Haskell, the actress who portrayed Marty then and continues to do so now, and Roger Howarth, the actor who portrayed Todd -- and has since been replaced by Trevor St. John.
Marty has come and gone on the show since 1993, but Todd has remained for most of that time, and while past writing teams have attempted to reform him to some extent – going so far as to have him raped by a madwoman -- he has remained a devious, manipulative, temperamental bully and, overall, an evil, dangerous man. I won’t go into the long and winding details here, but Todd during the last few months had been secretly caring for Marty after she suffered an accident that left her with amnesia. Todd’s original intentions were sinister, but in recent weeks he fell increasingly in love with Marty, all the while neglecting to tell her the truth about their past. Last week, Marty and Todd made love, with Marty unaware that she was with the man who raped her years ago.
As you might expect, a number of viewers are outraged by the insensitivity, inhumanity and overall creeping horror of this scenario. (Check out the heated column on this subject by former JackMyers contributor Marlena Delacroix and the blistering comments that follow it.) Todd raped Marty once again, they claim. It didn’t matter that he appeared to have reformed and was in love with her, or that their lovemaking was gentle and passionate and nothing at all like the violent atrocity Marty was made to endure years earlier. Nor did it matter that Marty consented, they say, because she was suffering amnesia and wasn’t in her right mind.
I have to agree with them. This tale, though well told, has been sickening given the history of these characters. I don’t believe that sex between two adults can be mutually consenting when one of the people involved has no idea what’s really going on, and especially when one of the two is a depraved brute who previously attacked the other. When Todd and Marty got together it may not have seemed like rape, but when Marty later learned the depth of Todd’s deception, her response was clearly that of a woman who had once again been violated in the worst possible way. It all seems horribly exploitative on the part of ABC. I am certain the network fully knew what it was doing, because it ran a PSA for the National Sexual Assault Hotline at the end of the episode in which Todd and Marty “made love.” Further, during the SOAPnet repeat of this episode, as the tension mounted and it became increasingly and alarmingly clear that Todd the Predator and Marty the Victim were going to have sex, a graphic in the lower left corner teased: “Todd’s Worst Crimes. Relive them all on SOAPnet.com.” Is nothing sacred?
ABC has always had a warped handle on the character of Todd. (Remember when ABC parent Disney briefly marketed a doll of this reprehensible rapist?) Sadly, in this instance the network had the opportunity to do something amazing with his long-running storyline, which has spanned two decades, and it would have been so simple. The writers had already established the inner conflict Todd was experiencing in the moments before he had sex with Marty. (He was even having flashbacks to the gang rape.) Rather than take her to bed, he should have broken down, confessed everything to her and taken her rage. There would have been no question at that time that Todd had indeed changed. That would have brought the saga full circle and been enormously satisfying for long-term viewers. It wouldn’t have excused anything Todd had done in the past, but it wouldn’t have been as revolting as the sight of him once again having his way with the woman he previously raped.
I wish ABC had shown more restraint and responsibility in the way it played this story. That said, I will compartmentalize my disgust and continue to enjoy the rest of the show. At present I cannot wait to tune in tomorrow and see what happens next on One Life to Live. But I can certainly understand why many people might throw up their hands and declare that they have had enough.


add this social bookmark link

Post a Comment

Reader Comments(4)
This is exactly the same thing with Luke and Laura...he raped her! Yet theirs is one of the greatest love stories ever. Why is it that Todd and Marty can't overcome their problems and pass issues (by the way she forgave him for the rape a long time ago before she got amnesia) and just be in love? Todd was wrong for not telling Marty everything, but he does really love her.
Posted at 11:31 AM on Nov 14, 2008 by Team Todd and Marty
I've been deeply horrified by the misogyny in this storyline. Remembering how brutally Todd raped Marty in the past, every action between them (with her both physically and mentally incapacitated) has caused my skin to crawl. This isn't titillating, it's disgusting. And I wish more rape victim advocacy groups would come out and state how deplorable this storyline has been because far less disturbing than the people screaming over the atrocity of this storyline are the large number of people online who turn themselves into knots trying to justify this second rape, and how Todd is perfectly justified because he thinkis he "loves" her. Sexual Abuse Advocacy groups should insist that ABC and OLTL do that public service announcement every day they continue this story because there are some people disturbingly confused over what constitutes rape.

Todd raped Marty. Again.
Posted at 05:52 PM on Nov 17, 2008 by L.W.
Great Column this week! I completely agree. Having Todd rape Marty again does nothing but exploit the viewers. It completely disregards the character growth made in this area. Unfortunately, this character growth is key to the core of who Todd Manning is and why the character achieved such popularity in the first place.

Re-writing Todd to have learned nothing from the gang rape does a disservice to many of us who loved him and rooted for him based on the fact that he had learned from his most heinous crime. Ron Carlivati has changed history to the point where no matter what Todd does or says, he has never and will never learn from what he has done to Marty. No one will ever again believe he will not rape in the future. And let's be honest, the longevity for rapists who never learn is not terribly impressive. Thank you, Ron Carlivati, for your "vision". You have killed the most epic character in the history of ABC daytime. You should be so proud.
Posted at 07:03 PM on Nov 17, 2008 by Snugglebug
Luke and Laura were fucked up and offensive. Todd and Marty as true romance would be beyond offensive.

I must say, that as a female viewer I've got nothing against dead babies in my entertainment - well, fictional dead babies of course. Pls. don't put us all in one stereotype.
Posted at 04:03 AM on Nov 18, 2008 by Wendell

media industry poll